Management accounting is a potent tool that can help organisations improve their business performance. It can inform and influence both long-term business strategy and annual operating plans, and through periodic reporting, provide feedback on the actual performance relative to operating plans.
Ideally, a robust management accounting process should underpin three critical areas of organisational performance:
- strategic planning i.e. in setting the strategic goals of the organisation
- tactical planning i.e. in shaping and implementing annual operating plans
- ‘health check’ i.e. in understanding the current performance of the organisation
Given below is a primer on each.
Strategic planning
Strategic planning is the process by which management defines the organisation’s goals for the long term, usually 2-3 years. A robust management accounting process can inform and influence strategic planning in multiple ways:
- to objectively assess the costs vs. benefits of strategic choices (e.g. cost of geographical expansion vs. its potential outcomes)
- to analyse the current strengths (e.g. good customer service) and vulnerabilities (e.g. concentrated customer base) of the organisation
- to apply relevant tools such as balanced scorecard in ensuring a balance among competing stakeholder expectations
- to produce financial forecasts that indicate the financial outcomes (e.g. revenue and profit growth %) of the strategic plans, and the financial requirements (e.g. capital needed for an expansion) for achieving the strategic goals.
A strategic management accounting process can enable management ‘develop and monitor its business strategy’ (Simmonds1).
Tactical planning
Tactical or annual planning is, essentially, converting the strategic goals into annual or near-term plans. Depending on how the organisation is structured, this is done at the level of the business unit or line of service. Tactical plans help the business units identify and seize immediate opportunities in the marketplace. They evaluate internal capabilities and assess gaps that the business unit must bridge in order to achieve its annual goals.
McKinsey2 first proposed the concept of ‘Value Drivers’ in 1994, where the focus is on identifying those factors in a business that are relatively more important than others in driving value for a business. A robust management accounting process can help identify the relevant Value Drivers that can then inform the preparation of the tactical plans.
As the strategic goals are converted into business-unit goals within the organisation, there is a potential for competing priorities to arise. Management accounting can analyse these priorities using financial analysis techniques (net present value analysis, or internal rate of return) allowing management to make an informed decision on trade-offs.
‘Health check‘
Periodic reporting of actual performance at a business-unit level along with an analysis of variance to annual plans is fundamental to understanding the current performance of the organisation and to identify areas of improvement. This is also usually combined with KPI reporting – commonly referred to as dashboards. It is, however, important the right KPIs are being measured – KPIs derived from the Value Drivers during tactical planning are more meaningful in assessing the actual performance.
While financial accounting statements are usually meant for external stakeholders like banks, management accounting can re-cast those statements (obviously without changing the overall results) to reflect a ‘management’ view to enable management understand the business performance better. For example, analysing costs as fixed, variable or semi-variable is a good way to understand flexibility in cost structure. Similarly understanding revenue composition by product or service categories and customers enables a greater understanding of business performance in that area.
In addition to the historical reporting noted above, it is also important for an organisation to undertake forecasting. Business conditions can change and assumptions originally made in the tactical plans (or, at times, even the strategic goals) may no longer be relevant. Forecasts help management understand the financial and business impact of the changed operating conditions so they can assess if any tweaks or changes are required to the tactical plans. In particular, cashflow forecasts encapsulate the combined effect of revenue and cost forecasts. Read my prior detailed article on this topic here.
Summary
Quite often management do not realise the direction in which their business is headed until it is too late. A robust management accounting process can help shape an organisation’s strategic and tactical plans, and provide a credible ‘health check’ of its current performance. Given that all businesses operate under the same economic conditions, management emphasis on a robust management accounting process could very well be a differentiator of success in the marketplace.
References
1.Simmonds, Ken (1981), ‘The Fundamentals of Strategic Management Accounting’, Institute of Cost and Management Accountants
2.Koller, Timothy (August 1994), ‘What is value-based management?’, McKinsey Quarterly (link accessed 27 June 2022)